More Questions & Answers


To send Al your questions and topics click here, then check back here for your answers.


Q: From Doug: Doug fishes Montauk for bass. His question is "How do you effectively chunk for bass in a running tide"?

A: Ideally I like to fish the last of the incoming and first of the outgoing tide. However, sometimes that does not work out and you can only fish in a running tide. In that situation I fish four rods using two different methods. The first is fishing with a fish finder rig and 6-12 ounce sinker. The leader to the 8/0 hook is 60 lb test mono 12 feet long. You drop the rig to the bottom and slowly walk the sinker back in the tide constantly feeling for the bottom and the weight of the chunk pulling in the tide. Typically you drop back from 150-200 feet behind the boat periodically checking for the bottom. I Like to fish these rigs inboard off the stern. The second method is to use leadcore or wire line with no weight. These are fished off both stern corners. Use a six foot leader to the hook. Slowly drop it back in the tide and feel for the bottom. When you feel bottom take up 3-4 turns on the reel to raise the chunk off the bottom. If no bites, than slowly drop back further feeling for the bottom and again take up 3-4 turns when you feel the bottom. You usually will have approximately 200 feet of line out. If you get a bite and miss the fish, drop back about ten feet. The fish will usually come back if the bait is still there. The leadcore and wire have no stretch, therefore make sure your drag is properly set and keep your rod at 45 degrees to absorb the fight of the fish. Many people pull the hook on a good fish because of too tight a drag and improper rod handling.

Q: From Steve: Steve is an avid fan of jigging for fluke. He wants to know want type of teaser to use?

A: I use white early in the season, them switch to chartreuse green woth silver krystalflash. I like a 3/0 hook. You can buy them at about $1.50 each or easily make them yourself. I usually make my own or have a fly tying buddy make them up for me over the winter. I use a Gamakatsu 3/0 Octopus hook tied with white and chartreuse green synthetic hair with a few strands of silver krystalflash.

Q: Paul Wolff from Point Lookout. Wants some tips on clam chummimg around the bridges in his area.

A: Clam chumming has been around for a long time. I remember doing it more than thirty years ago around Captree. It is a very effective method for taking striped bass. The only drawback is that you will primarily be catching schoolie fish below the 28 inch minimum size with an occasional keeper. But it is fun on light tackle. My preference is to fish dawn or late afternoon on the last three hours of the flood tide and the first two hours of the ebb tide. I anchor uptide of the bridge pilings, usually toward the sides of the bridge, not dead center. In the old days we would take a thawed 5 gallon can of clam bellies and dribble some over the stern of the boat to create a slick and then drift some clam bellies back on a 3/0 baitholder hook approximatel 150 feet. If no bite, than you would reel in an start your drop back again. Today, clam bellies are hard to come by. Ground frozen clam chum is what is available commercially. So today we use a specially made 5 gallon chum pot and put in the entire can of frozen clam chum. We use a fine wire mesh to prevent excess chum from creating too heavy a slick. We then lower the chum pot down off the stern just above the bottom and cleat it off. As I said before, this is light tackle fishing. Use a 6.5 foot medium bay rod with 15 lb test mono spooled onto a baitcaster capable of holding approximately 200 yards. Tie on a small black barrel swivel and about two feet of 25 lb test flourocarbon leader snelled to a 3/0 Gamakatsu baitholder hook. Bait up with fresh pieces of clam with the soft belly part or with clam bellies if you can get them. Free spool the line off the back of the boat approximately 150 feet. I am usually fishing with two to three people in the boat. When we start, one rod is fished with no spit shot and two are fished with varying weights of split shot. This is done to find the depth the fish are feeding at. Give a spot at least a half hour to produce the first fish. It sometimes takes that long to get them started. If there are no bites than move your location and start over. A word of caution. Clam chumming produces lots of small fish that must go back unharmed. First, net all fish. Also, this method sometimes results in fish taking the hook deep. If that happens, than cut the leader as close to the hook as possible and return the fish to the water.

Q: From Drew in Mt. Sinai. What do I think of Ambassadeur reels matched to a 6 1/2 foot Ugly Stik for Peconic Bay fluking?

A: I have been using an Ambassadeur 6000C for over 30 years and have taken many fluke, stripers and blues on this reel. I would recommend the 6500C3 spool with 20 lb mono. Make sure to clean both your rod and reel after each trip, back off the drag and spray the reel lightly with Superlube.

Q: From Kevin. He fishes on the Captain Lou out of Freeport and is interested in a custom rod, but the prices for a custom rod he thinks are too high. Suggestions!

A: Kevin, a true custom rod should perform better than the rod you are currently using. However, you should know that a custom rod is not just the fancy threadwork. A good custom fluke/flounder rod made from quality components is a minimum of $225 without any fancy butt wrap. If that is beyond your budget than consider a good production rod. The Cabelas catalog has some excellent rods to choose from.

Q: From kbookeyman. Wants to practice catch and release and is afraid that if he squeezes down the barb on the hook he will loose fish.

A: Squeezing down the barbs should be primarily on treble hook lures. It's for catch and release and for safety reasons. If you are using a single hook for bait, try a circle hook. Also, the secret to not loosing fish when caught on a barbless hook is to maintain no slack in the line when fighting the fish.

Q: From Tom on City Island. Want to recommend a rod and reel for fluking in the Sandy Hook area for around $100.

A: Tom, since you are a mate on a party boat, the outfit will get alot of use. I would recommend a Shimano TR100N reel which goes for approximately $70. I would match it with a Penn rod with ceramic guides and capable of handling up to 6 ounces of lead. The entire outfit should run you no more than $125-$150.

Q: From Rob: Why is a single hook better than a treble hook on a cod jig? Why do you use a swivel and split ring to attach a teaser to the dropper loop?

A: A single hook is more effective than a treble for several reasons. On a large fish, the single hook will hold better than the smaller treble. You tend to snag more smaller fish with the treble hooks and as get hung up more frequently in rocky bottom. Using a split ring and swivel, or just the swivel alone with allow the teaser to spin freely to attract more fish and not twist your line.

Q: From Unknown. He fishes cut bait for bluefish with circle hooks on a heavy leader attached to a 3-way swivel and is not getting any bites while others are catching fish. Any suggestions.

A: Eliminate the 3-way swivel and use a fishfinder rig. When you get a bite, do not strike the fish. Let him run and take up the slack by reeling into the fish. He will hook himself.

Q: From Chris 3515 - What is the best tide to fish the north shore harbors for spring flounder? Do yellow sinkers really work? What is the best bait for spring flounder?

A: I am not familiar with the west end north shore so I would check with the local tackle shops in the area. Typically you want some tide movement to carry your chum slick. Yes, yellow sinkers do work. Also, put some small yellow or florescent plastic 1.5 inch grubs on your hook. They are also quite effective. For bait, my personal favorite is fresh mussels. However, I would bring a variety off baits like sand worms and fresh clams. Bring plenty of chum. Fresh crushed mussels or frozen clam chum logs.

Q: From Adam: How to rig for offshore cod jigging?

A: The long range cod trips to Georges Bank can be both bait or jig fishing, depending on the conditions. For jig fishing the jigs range in size from 10-20 ounces depending on wind, tide and water depth. Jigs like the Bridgeport Vike, Norwegian or Crippled Herring are all effective. Make sure you take off the standard treble hook and put on a single 10/0 Siwash or Mustad tube hook. A flourescent pearl or green tube or skirt over the hook will add to its effectiveness. Tie the jig to a 3 foot piece of 80 lb. mono shock leader with a 4 inch dropper loop about 18 inches above the jig. Then attach a heavy split ring to the dropper loop and attach a heavy black barrel swivel to the split ring. Then take another of the above hooks with a 9 inch purple jelly worm and attach it to the barrel swivel. These hooks have open eyes that can be closed with the pair of pliars. At the other end of the leader tie on a heavy black ball bearing swivel and then tie your main line to the other eye of the swivel. There a basically two jigging techniques depending on your position on the boat. If you are up in the bow, then flip your jig uptide and bounce it along the bottom until you pass the bow to the downtide side. Reel up and repeat the process. If you are on the side of the boat then just drop the jig straight down to the bottom and start to yo yo the jig. Keep droping back two our three times to feel the bottom while you work the jig. If no bite then reel up and repeat the process. If you are not getting bites, watch those fishermen that are catching fish and follow their jigging style.

Q: From Dano: What are the advantages of using circle hooks?

A: The main advantage is that you won't gut hook the fish should you want to release it. Second, you will increase your hook up ratio. I have had success fishing circle hooks for striped bass, bluefish, tuna and fluke in the north, and tarpon, sailfish, grouper and snapper down south. The key to fishing these hooks is not to try to set the hook on the bite. You simply reel into the fish when you feel the bite and the fish literally hooks himself. Also, circle hooks do not have the same numbering system as other hooks. Buy them at a reputable tackle shop that stocks them and ask their advice on the proper hook size.

Q: From Pat and John: Spring Blackfish Tips Fishing from Point Lookout.

A: Blackfishing in the spring is a shadow of what it was in years past. Commercial pressure has severely reduced both the sping and fall recreational catch. However, you can still put some fairly decent catches from time to time. While you can target the many bridge structures in the greater Jones Beach area like the Meadowbrook, I would try to find some of the many inshore ocean rockpiles and structure that are outside Jones Inlet. Pick up some local charts that will show you the known wrecks in the area and give them a try. Also, try to do some searching on your own for some bottom structure. Standard tackle of a medium boat rod and reel loaded with 30 lb. spectra line. A #5 Virginia or 3/0 Gamakatsu Octopus hook snelled on 40 lb. leader. Bait can be fiddlers, green crabs or fresh clams. Spring blackfish usually are on the small side, with a good fish being 5-6 lb. However, there is always the chance of picking up a larger fish. Make sure you put back the spawning females.

Q: From Jerrold: Porgy Tips for Late Summer and Fall

A: Like blackfish, porgy fishing has shown a tremendous decline over the years. The best porgy fishing I had last year was from mid September into October from Orient Point, Montauk and off Block Island on charter fishing trips. I would check out the Long Island Fisherman for the names of charter boats from Montauk and Orient Point and call the captains for more information to schedule a trip. Chater boats from Montauk I can recommend are the Vivienne, Karen Sue, Lori Jay, Fisherman II, Breakaway, Blue Fin IV and Montauk.. From Orient Point - Nancy Ann, Orient Star and the Sundowner.

Q: From W.T. Tyler - Recommendations for Places to Fly Fish on Long Island In April.

A: I am not a freshwater fly fisherman and have only just started to fly fish in saltwater. I would recommend you contact one of the many fly fishing tackle shops on Long Island for more information or pick up a copy of the Long Island Fisherman.

Q: From Mike C. Wants a recommendation on a rod a reel combo for party boat fluking. Would prefer a Penn reel.

A: In trying to answer Mike's question, he failed to tell me where he does his party boat fluking. So to answer his question, I would recommend two combinations. One for bay and inlet fishing and one for ocean fishing. Also, not knowing Mike's budget, I will try to recommend a quality combination under $100. For bay and inlet fishing in relatively shallow water and light tides, you need an outfit capable of 1-5 ounces of lead. A 6 1/2-7 foot medium light boat rod and a Penn 9M or Mag 10 with 20 lb. mono. Look at rods like the Penn Power Stick PC3801ML, Ugly Stik BWB113066 or a Star Rod in the similar range. For ocean fluking, try a Penn 310 GTI loaded with 25 lb. mono. Look at rods from the same manufacturers that are medium action and can handle from six to ten ounces of lead. Also, check out your local reputable tackle shop for their recommendations as well.

Q: G Hook wants to know how to decipher weather forecasts for "reasonable conditions" to plan a party boat blackfish trip.

A: Weather forecasting maybe a science, but for me it is a "SWAG" (scientific wild ass guess") at best. Especially in the fall. The water and air temperatures can change rapidly. That difference in water and air temperatures is what causes wind. I have lost so many fall trips over the years, that I now plan for at least a 50% cancellation rate when settting up my fall blackfish schedule.

I try to look for a stable weather pattern for at least two days. I do most of my blackfishing from Montauk to Orient. That area allows us to usually find a productive fishing spot in the lee of the wind. However, sometimes that is not the case.

I would look for a weather forecast for wind no more than 10-15 mph and seas 2-3 feet. Any more than that, the boat will be bouncing around making it difficult to lay quietly on a piece of productive bottom since blackfish do not like a bait bouncing around.

Q: From Vinny: I am using Spider Wire for blackfish and like the sensitivity, but I am breaking the line on the structure when I attempt to set the hook. What am I doing wrong?

A: Vinny, Spider wire, or any of the other new super lines, require some special attention when fishing with them. If you are not familiar with the following knots I strongly advise you to buy a copy of a good knot book in a reputable tackle store.

When fishing for blackfish, cod, sea bass or any deep water bottom fish, here is how I rig up. It has proven the test of time with many successful catches.

1. I use 30 lb. test Spider Wire for all my bbottom fishing applications. For deep water (>100 feet) I first double over the Spider Wire about 24 inches and tie a Spider Hitch.
2. For blackfish, cod and sea bass I then tie on to the doubled spider wire approximately 25 feet of 50 lb. Ande mono. Join the two lines together with a double uni knot.
3. Tie on a black barrel swivel to the end of the 50 lb. mono. The tie on your terminal rigging to the 50 lb. mono.

The 50 lb mono serves three purposes:
- It is more abrasion resistant than the Spider Wire and barnacle encrusted bottom structure.
- It acts as a shock absorber when a big fish makes a final dive for freedom since it has more stretch than the spider wire.
- Should you get tangled with another angler, it is much easier to untangle mono than spider wire.
Also, when blackfishing, make sure your hooks are sharp. Very important. You don't need to swing hard since the line has no stretch. Also, slightly loosen up on your drag. You will land more fish.

Q: From Marty - Wants a recommendation for a spinning reel for flipping jigs from a boat to match a medium-heavy spinning rod.

A: There are many excellent reels out there to choose from. You will want a reel with a smooth drag and a capacity of approximately 200 yards of 12-15 lb. mono. I would go with either Penn, Shimano or Daiwa. There are several models in different price ranges from $60 and up.

Q: From Doug - Doug is floating chunks at the south shore bridges and is getting run offs but is not getting a solid hook up.

A: Try really sharpening your hooks. Also, try moving up to a larger hook, about a 7/0 Octopus style.

Q: From hrodri4142 - Wants to know about proper knots.

A: I can't think of anything that is more important to proper rigging than knowing the correct knot to use. There are some excellent books and videos on knot tying. My favorite is a paperback by Mark Sosin and Lefty Kreh. You can find it in any good tackle shop. Get the book and practice tying. You really only need to know about 6-8 knots for most fishing situations. They are: hook snell knot; perfection loop; uni-knot; Spider hitch; Trilene Knot; Improved clinch knot; dropper loop and Surgeon's loop.

Q: From Bill - Wants recommendations for a rod and reel to fish the south shore beaches.

A: Bill, I am not a surf fisherman, but I have a lot of friends who are. They have a selection of rods and reels for different situations. There is no all purpose rod and reel. However, you can come pretty close. For all around surf fishing, I would recommend a 10 foot medium action rod capable of handling 2-5 ounces. Choose a matching reel with a good drag and line capacity of 250 yards of 20 lb. mono. Whether you choose spinning or conventional is your choice. I would recommend you check out some of the better tackle shops on Long Island for tackle recommendations for the areas you will be fishing.

Q: From Travis Tate...Jigging Blues off Port Jefferson in October.

A: Blues are on the move and feeding heavily for their fall migration south. Since they are feeding very heavily they could be at any depth chasing bait. The waters off Port Jefferson is varied in depth all the way out to Middle Grounds where the depth can exceed 100 feet. If you are fishing on your own boat I would get out there early and first look for birds working. That is a sure sign that bass or blues are feeding. If there are no birds working you need to find the rip lines where the tide will push the bait. Blues and bass will take up station down tide of the structure to have the bait brought to them by the tide. Cruise around over known structure to see if you can read them on your bottom machine. Use a medium heavy boat rod of about 7 feet. A conventional reel with 30-50 test mono and 8 ounce diamond or slab jigs with a single 8/0 or 9/0 hook.

Q: From Unknown...Best bait and water temperature for cod?

A: Cod are not fussy eaters and will bight on most types of bait. However, the standard bait used is usually sea clams. A half of a large clam or a whole clam on a 5/0 beak hook on a 15 inch leader is the standard rig. Make sure you have some of the soft belly meat of the clam on the hook. As far as water temperature, cod usually like it in the mid to low 40 degree range. As the temperature goes below 40 degrees they become reluctant to feed.

Q: From Fred...Best colors and time to bucktail at Plum Gut?

A: Well Fred, now is the time. The daytime bucktailing is hot. Check with Bob at Wego Fishing Station in Southold for the best time and tides. He will also advise you on the best colors. White, purple and flourescent chatreuse are all effective colors. Make sure you put on a striper pork rind.

Q: From Paul...How to rig crabs for blackfish?

A: I use green crabs for blackfish in the fall. If I can get hermit crabs I prefer them. Use a # 5 Virginia blackfish hook snelled on 50 lb. leader. Cut the green crab in half with a pair of scissors. The inexpensive utility snips for about $3 work great. Snip of the legs and remove the back shell. Thread the hook through one socket and out the other. That's it.

Q: From Unknown...Wire Line Trolling Umbrella Rigs in the Freeport Area.

A: Umbrella rigs are very effective where there are concentrations of baitfish. I would work the Jones Inlet area and outside along the beach. Start out with 150 feet of wire out. If you have no hits go to 200 feet and continue to let out wire until you hit fish. Look for birds working and troll the edge of the school. Don't go through the center of the diving birds since you will scatter the school.

Q: From ClareBear...How do you catch live bunker?

A: Live bunker are caught by commercial fishermen by netting. To catch live bunker by a sport fisherman, we usually try to spot a school of bunker early in the morning and use a snagging rig to catch them. Most sport fishermen purchase them fresh from a reliable bait and tackle shop.

Q: From Unknown. What kind of rig do you use for seabass on wrecks and when is the best time to go?

A: I use a two or three hook hi-lo rig using 50 lb. leader material with 6 inch dropper loops. The first loop should be about 6 inches above the sinker and the next two should be spread about a foot apart. I use 4/0 baitholder hooks. Bait with squid strips or skimmer clam. The seabass season just open up. Inshore wrecks and rocks should hold fish this time of year. As the season progresses they will move to deeper areas, with the biggest fish being caught on the deeper wrecks in the ocean and Long Island Sound. One of my friends just fished a deep wreck in LI Sound and had three fish over 5 lb and one over 6 lb.

Q: From Tony - Where can he get a map of Moriches Bay?

A: If you are a boater I would strongly recommend you go into one on the many boat supply stores and get a bound laminated book of maps for your primary fishing areas. The stores usually carry a full selection.

Q: From Fred - Best tide to Fish for Striped Bass in Plum Gut?

A: This changes day deepending on weather, wind, time of year and the presence of bait in the water. Both ebb and flood tide will produce fish. Check with your local tackle shops familiar with the area for the latest information.

Q: From Jerry, Cold Spring - Where can he get GPS numbers for productive wrecks in Long Island Sound?

A: Wreck numbers are boat fishermens most guarded secret. You can get lists of known wrecks and obstructions off coastal navigation maps listed in latitude and longitude. I would recommend that you keep a log like most successful fishermen of productive spots you have fished. Also, when I had my own boat, I would take time during the "dog days" of summer you do some wreck hunting. When moving from one fishing spot to another, don't race at 20+ knots. Slow down and look at your bottom machine and note any wrecks and obstructions you might run across. Then check them out later in the season.


Q: From John: Is a Penn 209 reel okay for fluke and what sinker weight should I use?

A: The Penn 209 is a great reel for fluke. I would spool it up with 20lb. quality mono line, like Ande or Berkeley Big Game.
As far a what sinker weight, it depend on how deep you are fishing and the speed of the current. You always want to be in contact with the bottom. For in the bay, 2-3 ounces is usually adequate. In the inlets and along ocean beaches you may need to go up to 6 ounces. For true ocean fluking in deep water like Ambrose Channel or off Montauk and Gardiners Island where there are deep dropoffs and strong tides, it's not uncommon to fish 10 ounces and even higher.

FLUKE FISHING
We have been getting lots of questions on fluke fishing. Questions on how to rig for bait fishing and bucktailing; specific knots to use and how to tie them; areas to fish from one end of Long Island to the other. The best thing I can recommend on sharpening you skills on fluking is to pick up Don Kamienski's book and video tape on fluking, and get a copy of "Knot Tying" by Mark Sosin and Lefty Kreh. They are all great sources of information. Kamienski's book and video are loaded with great information and tips on fluking. Knot Tying by Sosin and Kreh is essential for your knowledge of proper knots and how to tie them.

Q: From Tom from Babylon: Tom is new to the fishing game a has bought a Penn 5500 spinning reel and 7 foot medium heavy rod to match. His question is can he fish this rig for fluke, flounder, weaks, blues and bass? He just started fishing on party boats.

A: Sure Tom, you can fish for these fish with this set up. It may be a little heavy for fluke and flounder. I would not recommend it on a party boat. Spinning reels are for casting, and casting on a party boat is a no no.

This would be a great set up for pier and jetty fishing. If you want to fish on a party boat get a conventional reel that will hold approximately 200 yards of 25 lb test mono line. Check with your local tackle shop for the proper reel in your budget.

Q: From Hughie from Flanders. Hughie fishes for fluke in Western Peconic Bay and has had not much luck. He wants to know any favorite spots I can recommend.

A: The fluke were super in the Peconic area early in the season, but they have moved east to the Gardiners Island area, east of the Ruins. I would run through Shinnecock Canal and fish the inlet channel and just outside the jetties. Check with Altenkirch Tackle in Hampton Bay for the latest information on area, bait and tides.
Please pick your day carefully. Shinnecock Inlet can be very dangerous in bad weather.


For more answers to your questions Click Here.




Return to Al Goldberg's Tackle Corner or Dave's Homepage.